indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
by StLGooner » Thu Sep 13, 2018 7:17 pm
indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
by LegendaryKeown » Thu Sep 13, 2018 7:18 pm
StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
by StLGooner » Thu Sep 13, 2018 7:37 pm
LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
by LegendaryKeown » Thu Sep 13, 2018 8:08 pm
StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
by indy23 » Thu Sep 13, 2018 9:36 pm
LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
Goals? Assists? They would prove it.
Not that he is though. Iwobi took his team to a World Cup
by StLGooner » Fri Sep 14, 2018 12:29 pm
LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
Goals? Assists? They would prove it.
Not that he is though. Iwobi took his team to a World Cup
by Zenith » Fri Sep 14, 2018 12:57 pm
StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
Goals? Assists? They would prove it.
Not that he is though. Iwobi took his team to a World Cup
Their stats are identical pretty much, but still what does that prove? Nothing.
So Iwobi took his team to the world cup and you think that proves he's better than Pulisic? So I guess he's better than Alexis too huh? See how shit that logic is?
by StLGooner » Fri Sep 14, 2018 1:19 pm
Zenith wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
Goals? Assists? They would prove it.
Not that he is though. Iwobi took his team to a World Cup
Their stats are identical pretty much, but still what does that prove? Nothing.
So Iwobi took his team to the world cup and you think that proves he's better than Pulisic? So I guess he's better than Alexis too huh? See how shit that logic is?
It's a piece of flawed reasoning.
It's also fictive and borderline preposterous to suggest he carried Nigeria to the World Cup.
Heck, Alex is yet to become a nailed-on starter for Nigeria.
He did his bit, nothing more nothing less.
by LegendaryKeown » Fri Sep 14, 2018 2:14 pm
StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
Goals? Assists? They would prove it.
Not that he is though. Iwobi took his team to a World Cup
Their stats are identical pretty much, but still what does that prove? Nothing.
So Iwobi took his team to the world cup and you think that proves he's better than Pulisic? So I guess he's better than Alexis too huh? See how shit that logic is?
by StLGooner » Fri Sep 14, 2018 2:17 pm
LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
Goals? Assists? They would prove it.
Not that he is though. Iwobi took his team to a World Cup
Their stats are identical pretty much, but still what does that prove? Nothing.
So Iwobi took his team to the world cup and you think that proves he's better than Pulisic? So I guess he's better than Alexis too huh? See how shit that logic is?
Sanchez has more goals and assists, so kind of the obvious differentiation. If Pulisic was better than Iwobi, he'd have more assists and goals in a far, far easier league.
by LegendaryKeown » Fri Sep 14, 2018 2:19 pm
StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
Goals? Assists? They would prove it.
Not that he is though. Iwobi took his team to a World Cup
Their stats are identical pretty much, but still what does that prove? Nothing.
So Iwobi took his team to the world cup and you think that proves he's better than Pulisic? So I guess he's better than Alexis too huh? See how shit that logic is?
Sanchez has more goals and assists, so kind of the obvious differentiation. If Pulisic was better than Iwobi, he'd have more assists and goals in a far, far easier league.
Not true at all actually.
by StLGooner » Fri Sep 14, 2018 2:27 pm
LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:indy23 wrote:Would just mean we would need to sign someone to replace him. Pulisic.
Two different types of players really. Pulisic plays out wide mostly.
He probably is better than Iwobi though. I say that with no American bias.
Any stats to back that up?
What that he's better than Iwobi?
How would stats prove that? They wouldn't is the answer.
Goals? Assists? They would prove it.
Not that he is though. Iwobi took his team to a World Cup
Their stats are identical pretty much, but still what does that prove? Nothing.
So Iwobi took his team to the world cup and you think that proves he's better than Pulisic? So I guess he's better than Alexis too huh? See how shit that logic is?
Sanchez has more goals and assists, so kind of the obvious differentiation. If Pulisic was better than Iwobi, he'd have more assists and goals in a far, far easier league.
Not true at all actually.
Why not? They both play the same position and Pulisic played in a easier league.
A winger is supposed to give goals and assists. I seriously doubt Pulisic gives more workrate
by LegendaryKeown » Fri Sep 14, 2018 2:33 pm
StLGooner wrote:
Well just watch them play. You can see the difference. You can actually see the difference in skill level. Stats don't tell you everything. If you just went by stats, there would be so many players that look worse than other players, but are actually better. You can see that in about every sport.
He definitely has a good work rate. Kid runs his head off. Is it better than Iwobi's? Who cares, that's besides the point as we're talking about over all skill, not work rate. You can have a good work rate and be shit.
by StLGooner » Fri Sep 14, 2018 2:35 pm
LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:
Well just watch them play. You can see the difference. You can actually see the difference in skill level. Stats don't tell you everything. If you just went by stats, there would be so many players that look worse than other players, but are actually better. You can see that in about every sport.
He definitely has a good work rate. Kid runs his head off. Is it better than Iwobi's? Who cares, that's besides the point as we're talking about over all skill, not work rate. You can have a good work rate and be shit.
There is no difference in skill level. In the end, Gervinho was skillful but had no end product. I'd say Gervinho was more skillful than Pulisic and Iwobi combined
by LegendaryKeown » Fri Sep 14, 2018 2:35 pm
StLGooner wrote:LegendaryKeown wrote:StLGooner wrote:
Well just watch them play. You can see the difference. You can actually see the difference in skill level. Stats don't tell you everything. If you just went by stats, there would be so many players that look worse than other players, but are actually better. You can see that in about every sport.
He definitely has a good work rate. Kid runs his head off. Is it better than Iwobi's? Who cares, that's besides the point as we're talking about over all skill, not work rate. You can have a good work rate and be shit.
There is no difference in skill level. In the end, Gervinho was skillful but had no end product. I'd say Gervinho was more skillful than Pulisic and Iwobi combined
Meh, agree to disagree then.