Goonersworld

Who is it?

Seaman or Schmeichel were that damn good that no other keeper touches them.

But we can only pick one.

So I've voted

Schmeichel.

Seaman second best. Schmeichel is the best though.

The worst PL keeper ever is probably Kirkland. Not the worst ever to play, but the worst to consistently play. He was shocking.

Schmeichel or Cech

De Gea probably the outmost talented, his year last year/year before I forgot was Messi/Ronaldo level

Someone needs to explain Joe Hart, joint most Golden Gloves and City's defence wasn't on the level of past Arsenal, United or Chelsea sides.

I always thought Hart was average to good, never great.

I think Hart was an excellent keeper before he started do head and shoulders shit

Schmeichel by far

How is Reina not on the list?

Reina was never better than any of the list imo

Dynamite wrote:How is Reina not on the list?

Because he's not on their level, they are a lock for top 5 regardless of order - but I put the option of other.

I think Reina lacked the prescence to be commanding in the PL, good keeper though.

Schmeichal takes it, cech pre injury might have been as good.

I love seaman but nayim and ronaldinho violated him.

Isn't he the clean sheet goat of the PL?

Yes, he is with 47,02%
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Premier_League_goalkeepers_with_100_or_more_clean_sheets

Reina was very good. Certainly in the level of vds

Lehmann?