Gibbs is a solid tier two player, if he could play as a back-up to a decent right back he would be worth keeping, however if we want to challenge for trophies we need to improve our back-ups ... if we can sell for 15m and replace with a better player (and there are at least fifty better right backs the him) then we should be looking to do just that ....
What we really need is two quality right backs who can play defence and attack in a 3 5 2 line-up ... that's not going to happen in one window so we might as well keep Gibbs as a back-up .... but he's NOT A STARTER .....