DiamondGooner wrote:GBLShorty wrote:But he could do that with Xhaka/Elneny if they are deployed like they should be and not as box to box players that Wenger failed miserably with.
Xhaka could be a good defensive player if paired with soem protection, ie defenders who defend and not ball play and a another defensive midfielder.
Nope, he doesn't have the mind for it, doesn't even want to do it.
Elneny does though, which is why he pushed his way into the squad, no one else wanted to do DM, which is why with him and Torriea we'll finally have decent options in that position.
I loved it at school, CB and CDM were my fav positions, I used to love slide tackling mofo's, that's why it irks me that we don't have one at AFC.
He did in Germany were he was a proper '6' like N'Zonzi/Carvalho and was even scouted by Bayern before we snatched him, hes just been paired with pussys who only attack and do no defensive work, if paired with a ball winner/shuttler/b2b type (a decent one of the 3, not a squaddy like Elneny) he would have so much more room to play his game, he could be like Manu Petit, i think our staff know this, thats why hes just had a contract extension.
I think we would have seen better results from him if he was paired in a midfield like this...
----Coqulin(ball winner)-----Ramsey(CM)
-----------------------Xhaka (DLP)----------------
----Back 4>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
where he does not have to run, hes only really been played in this position maybe 3-4 times, and that is his true position.
He would be like Ozil where he only has to focus on his area of the pitch, he does not have the legs to be a midfielder.
And i agree with you about Elneny.