theHotHead wrote:thebigbangtheo wrote:I admittedly was reluctant to the notion of him requiring a loan period away for the simple reasons of acknowledging the good attacking potential he possesses, and that with a bit of stringent education from our defensive coaches with regards to the art and principles of defending that he was clearly deficient in, those could thus be readily addressed.
The massively marked overall improvement delivered by our defenders as a collective last season, is why I still have reason to think that Jover and co could've done something similar with this fella on a one-to-one basis.
However, that obviously wasn't deemed the best or more practical way of getting him to where it is that he needs to be in order to dispel the negativity created by some of his later below par outings that highlighted him as a weak spot following on from such a bright start in the team.
That his attacking prowess was never the issue with regards to his footballing ability, I hope that like Saliba before him, this stint at Marseille also comes to act as his proving ground in stepping up to the level required for the Premier League, and make the relatively low fee charged for their purchase of Guendouzi significantly more than worthwhile in brokering a good working relationship benefiting both clubs. Maybe we should've included Reiss Nelson as well.
Got to pull you up on this massively marked improvement in defending last season, 2 points I need to make. First, we conceded 48 goals last season compared to 39 the season before, so there was no improvement in defending, it was worse. Second, even if there was an improvement it wasn't down to our defensive coaches - last season we had a new GK, RB and CB, they didn't coach anyone they replaced the back line.
Its why I call Arteta a cheque-book manager because I don't see any coaching taking place anywhere.
My assessment regarding the teams defensive output last year, is primarily based upon what they managed to produce both individually and as a collective via their performances.
I considered Tomiyasu's efforts at right back to be a marked improvement upon what had gone before him from Bellerin, Cedric and Maitland-Niles.
I considered White's efforts at right center half to similarly be significantly better overall than what I'd previously witnessed from Sokratis, Holding or Chambers.
It was already established that despite easily being the best of the aforementioned bad bunch, we could only see the best of what Luiz had to offer by looking in a rear view mirror. Although undoubtedly still having a couple of rough edges to his diamond, Magalhaes...need I really say anymore?
Similar to Magalhaes, it was already established that Tierney was undoubtedly good enough, with the only murmurings arising from the disappointment we couldn't give Monreal the elixir of life and youth, or Tierney the same operation as Wolverine and infuse him with Adamantium.
The issue of the injuries to Tomiyasu and Tierney in particular and to a lesser extent White, are much, much more relevant in my opinion as to why our improved defensive displays didn't bear the harvest it once promised, as opposed to crunching numbers in search of the truth as it brings to mind Disraeli's quote of 'Lies, damned lies and statistics', but to each their own.
In having eradicated many of the debilitating traits that were all the too prominent before and culminate in almost going through the entire season without conceding a goal from a corner or something like that, if this was achieved without any influence from Arteta's coaching staff then kudos to the players.
However, with Arteta and co simply drinking tea and playing on their phones all day, I myself can only come to the conclusion then that George Graham must be hiding out somewhere in London Colney and secretly coaching the defenders from behind that strange looking mobile shrubbery...although, the lack of 'OFFSIDE!' being bellowed and arms being raised in unison so as to make the queen's guard jealous, does admittedly pour cold water on that theory.