Angelito wrote:Luzh 22 wrote:Angelito wrote:Luzh 22 wrote:Angelito wrote:Rafa Benitez would have this side competing for top-4 minimum and he's at Newcastle.
Do you really believe this?
Poor man's Jose Mourinho with an ego larger than the real Mourinho.
Please.
A manager who's won La Liga twice with the same club that Emery later managed and failed to win anything with, has reached the UCL Final twice - winning one of 'em, has won two UEFA Cups/EL, and is Liverpool's greatest modern day manager—who is also the reason why Newcastle are even in the PL and is the reason why there's even talk of them being in it next season over Emery?
Yes, he'd have this side battling for top-4 minimum.
We don't have a bad squad. A top manager would easily finish 4th with this squad.
But apparently, it seems, playing 8 defensive players—3 CBs, 2 FBs, and 2 DMs, sometimes 3, against West f'kin Ham has become the new Arsenal way.
What happened the last time Benny was in charge of a club in La Liga? And since Benny did that with Valencia, football has changed a lot.
Question you should ask yourself is "could benny win La Liga with Valencia now?". I think we both know the answer to that question.
He wouldn't win La Liga right now because Barca have Messi and there's Simeone—the best manager in the world for a budget side.
Also, the last and only time Emery managed a big club, he finished 2nd in a one-horse race, whilst also getting absolutely embarrassed by Barca and squandering a 4 goal first leg advantage.
The point isn't restricted to one Benitez. The fact is any top manager, or an ambitious manager, would have us challenging for fourth minimum. Also, no top manager would field 8 defensive players against West Ham. And it's not the first time he's done this.
The Arsenal job appears to be too big for Emery and nowhere in his job description is it stated that he has to challenge for the title. That says it all.
I don't understand why people keep saying any other manager like Klopp, Poch or Guardiola would have us battling for top 4 minimum. All of their squads are better than ours.
United's squad is better than ours too.
I said this on the West Ham Match Thread because someone else made the same point that you have. But we have the 6th best squad in the league. And it's not like we're 6th best with just one or two players short of being within the top 4 best squads in the league, we are miles behind the other sides in terms of balance, depth and quality.
If Emery got us 4th with the 6th best squad in the league, that would be a minor miracle.
I agree that his tactics and team selections have been very poor in recent weeks, and I can't fathom why he's alienated Ozil when even having him as an option would be more useful than not having him in the squad at all. But you can't deny this situation is largely a mess of Wenger's, Gazidis's and Kroenke's own making.
The truth is the competition for the top 4 spots is more difficult than it's ever been. The previous set up spent irresponsibly, bought the wrong profile of players, let our prized assets leave for free transfers and continued to give mediocre players big contracts which made us hard to sell them.
In stark contrast, the other teams bought responsibly, spent big if needed, sold good players but developed younger players and targeted/reinvested in areas of their team they know needed strengthening. Other teams appeared to have a strategy, whereas we've seemed to have a bit of a scattergun/reactive approach to things up until the club's restructure.
Based on our league position, Emery has us roughly where a lot of us expected us to be when he took over.
I don't think we're good enough to break into the top 4 personally, but objectively, we are still in with a shout and we are still in the Europa League.
What more were you expecting from him this season relative to our season objectives?
He was always going to have a bit of a 'free hit' this season.