Mustafi wrote:Pudpop wrote:Mustafi wrote:Maybe I'm too harsh on him, but I don't see how he can benefit us next season.
He's way worse than Auba, Laca, Mkhi, Özil, Ramsey and not better than Perez or even Lord Welbeck.
If his contract is extended so that he can be loaned out, I would understand. But keeping him? He would only get some odd league cup or EL games. Better for him and us, if he played a season elsewhere.
1. He's much better than Welbeck
2. He's homegrown and from our academy
3. Not every players needs to be a first team regular.
Gibbs might not have been the greatest arsenal player of his generation but he cost us nothing and got a job done as a squaddie.
Also, I don't think I need to point out how much Ramsey has improved in the last 6 years since he was Iwobi's age. And Iwobi has shown just as much talent as Ramsey did back then.
Nothing against a good squad player, who gets the odd game now or then, but how would that help Iwobi to improve? Specially at 22, he's at an age in which he should play more regular. I don't think we should offer him that. He has too many flaws.
Let him improve on a loan elsewhere and then return to us, if he got better imo.
Keeping him won't help to know if he's gonna make it or not.
Completely agree that a loan would be best for him buddy, doesn't mean we shouldn't extend his deal first though and hope he comes good. He needs to either get games here under Emery or go elsewhere with a strict manager and learn from his mistakes.
He's had it too easy, got too cocky and needs a real season where he buckles down and works hard, whether here or elsewhere.
Completely in favour of his new deal though.