jayramfootball wrote:theHotHead wrote:jayramfootball wrote:theHotHead wrote:jayramfootball wrote:theHotHead wrote:jayramfootball wrote:Ach wrote:Last season, Europa league is a distraction. Not worth it
This season, moving up 2 to 3 places in the league is progress.
Obviously
Fixed.
No its not, because we shouldn't have finished 8th in the first bloody place Jay!!
Thats like losing half your money gambling then spending the rest of the night trying to win it back, leaving the casino even and saying coming out even is improvement from when you went in.
Arteta can only be judged on what he took over.
In your analogy it wasn't him that lost the money at the casino, so he is not just even if he gets us to 5th/6th this year, he's ahead.
So far in his first 18 months he's improved us - but not enough.
This season a move up to 5th/6th would be significant.
That's some reaching Jay!!
Lets forget the 2019-20 season, Arteta in his full season got 1.78 points per game, Emery managed 1.95 in his full season.
So Arteta has taken us backwards. Forget half year accounts, its the full year accounts that matter!
Arteta took over mid season.
You can not ignore the fall from the end of Emery's first season to the point Arteta took over.
We had 23 points from 18 games when Arteta took over in the 19/20 season. 1.28 points per game.
Once Arteta took over it rose to 1.65 points per game over the following 20 games.
'Full-year accounts' mean nothing at all in assessing a manager if he didn't manage for the full year.
Perhaps you misunderstood my post. I am saying ignore the 2019-20 season for both Arteta and Emery, lets focus on their full seasons!
Emery full season after taking over from Wenger, 1.95 points per season.
Arteta full season after taking over from Arteta (2020-21 season), 1.78 points per season.
Both managers took over a club in turmoil, Emery's was moreso, because he had the weight of Wenger on his shoulders too.
It doesn't matter what Emery did in his first season - that has nothing to do with what was actually handed over to Arteta.
You can't ignore 19/20. That was when the handover actually happened! What was handed over was a team who had taken 23 points from 18 matches and were in crisis.
Right now were are in better shape than when Arteta took over. Not by much mind you.
But we have improved.
Of course it does, that was the previous season and the squad was very similar, it went wrong for Emery doesn’t mean the squad was bad.
Just look at Chelsea and Lampard and Tuchel. The fact is Arteta has made very poor use of the squad and has also cut out other options like Saliba, Mavropanos, Ozil, Guendouzi and to some extent Martinelli and Pepe and ESR.
It’s been an awful example of man and squad management, I’ve not seen another manager make so many shocking decisions.
You make so many excuses for Arteta it’s ridiculous. Under Arteta we went from 5th (almost 4th) to 8th, there’s zero debate about that, this despite complete backing in the transfer market.